At Headley Hardware our mission is to provide you with best-in-class customer service. That holds true when it comes to the convenience and time savings you get when you take advantage of our variety of services we offer! If you're starting on a project and would prefer to rent the tools and equipment you need instead of buying it, come to Headley's Hardware. We offer tool rental and equipment rental to Greencastle, IN and the surrounding areas. If you need a self storage unit for rent, we have those too! You can expect a painless return policy, and don't forget to ask about our discounts for senior citizens, active military, and first responders.

Photo of employee mixing paint

At Headley Hardware, we strive to provide valuable services beyond just selling products. As one of the top paint stores in West Central Indiana, our custom paint color matching system is one of the most popular services we offer. If you're looking to refresh your home and need to match a color, bring us a picture or swatch and we can custom match paint to your exact specifications.

Paint Matching

Looking to paint your walls to match your favorite rug, piece of furniture or even artwork? Bring in a picture of the item and we’ll match the color perfectly with our computerized paint color matching system. We have two complex paint mixing station including color analysis, helping Headley Hardware be your destination for paint matching in Greencastle. 

Key Cutting/Re-Keying

Don't know where to find a place to make duplicate keys for your car, doors, mailbox, or safe? Headley Hardware can do key cutting for you!  Having an extra set of keys is always great, especially if they get lost or worn out. If you need to re-key your entry or locksets, bring them to Headley Hardware for our re-keying services. We also copy computer chip keys.

Pipe Cutting/Threading

We carry a variety of plumbing supplies, and can cut PVC, galvanized and black iron piping for you. Bring it on in and we'll help you get your piping cut. We also offer pipe threading at Headley Hardware!

Small Engine Repair

Your lawn equipment requires servicing and repairing just like your vehicle. Our small engine repair shop is a full-service department dedicated to repairing anything from mowers, power tools, and even kerosene heaters of all types.

Pipe Cutting/Threading

We carry a variety of plumbing supplies, and can cut PVC, galvanized and black iron piping for you. Bring it on in and we'll help you get your piping cut. We also offer pipe threading at Headley Hardware!

Glass Cutting

At Headley Hardware we cut glass and plexiglass cutting. We'll cut a variety of glass types to the size specifications you need. Stop by for our glass cutting services. 

Screen & Window Repair

We repair many types of window & door screens. Bring it on in and we'll have our in-house specialist fix it quickly. We also repair windows and doors. Stop by today and ask an associate how we can help you!

Lamp Repair

Has your lamp stopped working? Bring it to Headley hardware and we can repair your lamps and other small household items! 

Electrical Wire Cutting

Have a big electrical project your are working on? Come to Headley's and we'll cut electrical wire by the foot for you. It makes it easier knowing you can get the amount of electrical wire you need, cut to your exact specifications at Headley's.